Any scientific evidence for astrology

Unpublished Study of Unaspected Planets (1975)
  1. Astrology: Is it scientific?
  2. Where Do Zodiac Signs Come From? Here's the True History Behind Your Horoscope
  3. Most Popular
  4. Download our free Chrome extension.

Like those who would have us believe in flying saucers, matriarchies, extrasensory perception and the like, Professor Spector falls back on the argument that we have not proved that astrology is nonsense i. One cannot demonstrate the nonexistence of something.

For learning a little bit more about this subject

If the believer in the unicorn acknowledges that the last-claimed unicorn turned out to be a pony with a party hat but insists that there may be a unicorn behind the next tree, we can say merely that science always leaves open every possibility, but accepts as existing only that which offers at least indirect observation of material evidence of its existence.

If we were to find that there are correlations of celestial events and personality characteristics, then we would, despite our incomprehension about what mechanism might connect the two, take astrology seriously - just as we would assume from the correlation of the tides and the position of the moon that one has something to do with the other, even if we had no idea what. But every serious attempt to find the sorts of correlations claimed by astrologers has found that no such correlations exist. That astrologers use maps of the heavens that have been obsolete for thousands of years and that astrology sees some small, distant objects exerting a greater force on us than some close, large objects contrary to our observation that every known force of nature weakens as mass diminishes and distance increases further justify the denial of astrology that would be justified by the absence of correlations.

Astrology truly is both a science, in its unique right as a body of knowledge, and definitely an art- an art of intepretation. Synthesis is required with astrology, and it can be quite complex. Once studied, experienced,and put to practice, one can begin to understand how useful astrology can be in many areas of life, not being hemmed in by black and white facts that require explanation in how something works. Life really isn't capable of being measured as in a laboratory; besides, what works fine in a laboratoty setting generally tends to work far less reliably in the real, outside world, if at all.

Sorry, I can't really tell if this is satire we need to get on that sark mark thing or not but I am interested in the "studies" that where mentioned. I find it amazing that people who criticize on astrology, have no given knowledge on it. Our personalities are not determined by the location of the stars, it's determined by the location of the planets.

The stars are used as constellations. Gemini constellation, Leo constellation. When you were born the planets were situated in the sky. In other words the orbit of each planets create a zodiac belt, which is divided into 12 sections. That is why we have 12 zodiac signs, so if you were born June 4th for instance, the sun was in the constellation Gemini. So before you try to criticize, know your facts. Have you ever heard of spellcheck? Whenever I read an article especially in a creditable journal like PT that has multiple spelling mistakes, it's hard for me to take what the author is saying seriously.

If you cared about what you were writing, you'd have probably proof-read it. Nitpicking aside, I agree that the movements of the planets and stars maaaaybe with the exception of the moon and sun have little or no effect on people's behavior or personalities. I do, however, think there is enough supporting evidence to suggest that the time of year that a person is born can directly effect their base personality, as well as their behavior from year to year. For example, both of my parents were born in mid-winter, and both of them are very conservative and cautious people, especially when it comes to finances, resources, and predicting the thoughts of others.

My mother Dec. Sagittarius , in particular, has actually been diagnosed with depression and mild bipolar symptoms, and my father Jan. Aquarius has always exhibited signs of extreme, bipolar-like mood swings. Both my grandmothers were depressive-bipolar, but one was born in winter and one in spring. The dyslexia was inherited from my maternal grandfather, though I'm not sure when his birthday was. Either way, I think all those little coincidences are very interesting from a statistical standpoint, and that there could definitely be something rooted in factual patterns behind astrology.

Perhaps they dismissed the value of the piece to the degree of not even scanning through it? I can consider it, to some degree, for the personality attributes- but not the 'controlling destiny' aspect. Just a couple random thoughts from someone who woke up in the night to get s glass of water..

  1. scorpio february 24 birthday astrology.
  2. virgo daily horoscope 20 march 2020?
  3. Search form.
  4. horoscope february 14 cusp.
  5. astrological series the astromusical house of gemini!
  6. Where did zodiac signs come from?.

Please hire a great editor for your online content. Poorly written and grammatically incorrect articles make me doubt how much time was put into your research. There is a site with photographs grouped by the sun, moon and ascendant signs of the astrological chart called "Astrofaces". People send their photos. It seems interesting.

Why Astrology Isn't Real Science

It's stuff happening her on earth that is the culprit. You have an incredibly limited understanding of astrology The preceding statement does in fact support astrology but you would have to understand the phenomenon to see it. And hopefully everyone is aware that there are, at the very least, two giant celestial bodies in our solar system that have a significant influence of life on earth, which could possibly mean the leap of faith to other celestial bodies having similar effects on earth events is not really that far a leap.

Astrology: Is it scientific?

I find it very amusing to think that many people think that science has disproven astrology. This is a falacy and in no way even begins to be true. There have been some rather ludicrous studies that pretend by being designed to fail. If you want to know what a real scientist would do to find out what is up with astrology. Please look at his website as it has real science and not silly studies about women looking for a man and havin ludicrous conclusions meant to make the reasearcher look good. How inappropriate!

Where Do Zodiac Signs Come From? Here's the True History Behind Your Horoscope

Now please let us know more details on it. Such as the scientific! Small modification "they're not" instead of they aren't. You have quite a few typos, no offense. Also, I am supposedly bipolar and born on March 2nd. I too have penchant for novelty-seeking behavior and am male, which is surprising; though, that could be attributed to my so-called "mania. I read a lot, of studies. I've never seen any of these studies, furthermore many studies are needed to show a connection.

Most Popular

Where are the links to these studies? Who conducted them? When where? Please rewrite your article with proper links and citations. May I please be provided with the links to your sources? I'd like to get to know more on this subject : Thank you very much. There are two things out-side and inside, spiritual and materialistic, odd and even etc, Science happens to be in the materialistic side as it needs evidence of materialistic value and we are trying to compare or justify other the spiritual with it.

  • 3 january horoscope sagittarius or sagittarius!
  • baraqijal taught astrology.
  • horoscope aries 9 january 2020.
  • The New Age of Astrology?
  • Is There Any Scientific Basis Behind The Astrology?!
  • Navigation menu.
  • I think the comparison basis is wrong. I have heard many prediction and most of them have come true, One was, I will get angry with the family and will never return after marriage, which was funny to me as I was just 8 or 9 year old when this was said, I even forgot it, late at 33 year it so happened many things changed i left the home angry and never went back I am 50 year old now, still have not gone back home, even if l like to.

    Now what scientific proof can be given for this , nothing except my recorded experience, which cannot be easily repeated. Out of curiosity, I learned astrology for over 5 years and found solution of most of the issues myself and have been a source to confidence and guidance to many,.

    • When astrology is tested by science!
    • sagittarius weekly tarot february 16 2020!
    • most famous astrologer in pakistan?
    • Why Are Millennials So Into Astrology? - The Atlantic;
    • Astrologers fail to predict proof they are wrong.
    • One recent issue, I got a chart of person who was declared brain dead and reputed hospital asked the family to take patient back, some of the people whom I studied gathered and analyzed the chart, we had different opinion, but finally we all said, keep him there for 4 more days, the chart is promising recovery but he will not be the same person rest of the life.

      The lady agree and requested the hospital to keep him for few more days, the hospital agreed, we as anyone were waiting for the good news, on the 5 day, she called up and said he has recovered and will be discharged in two days, but he is not the same person he has difficulty in coordinating things, this happened couple of months back. I've studied astrology for 30 years now. When I meet a Gemini male in particular, I don't even bother to try and get them to understand that there really is something real going on with astrology.

      I feel sorry for them on that account as they are missing out on a whole world of helpful and useful knowledge. You'll soon see how the planets influence you on a daily basis. It's as simple as that. Your loss if you don't, astrology is the most amazing and enlightening subject I ever came across, science included. That's a bit harsh on the Gemini, Starlove. I myself am a Gemini Sun and have a deep appreciation for Astrology.

      Download our free Chrome extension.

      Furthermore, an Aries conjunction of the moon, Venus and Eris in the eighth house is also present. Yes I am analytical, but that doesn't stop me from testing the waters with an idea that is statistically accurate, but not currently explainable. Although it gnaws at me to find an explanation, I still believe in it's validity based on the results of numerous case studies.

      Given the right Gemini, they are capable of in-depth analysis into something without apparent scientific grounding. It is very strange of a scientist and a skeptical to be sure of anything really So isn't it very bold to say something so absolute as something has nothing do with another thing? That the workings of our psyche "brains"???! So what about the moon having actual observable physical effects on the E e arth, its waters, plants, inhabitants, the periodical occurrences of natural phenomena e.

      Check out Magisociety They have empirical data and are making money on the stock market with their findings. They have found common astrological aspects for cheaters and sexual addicts To say that astrology can be scientific is not necessarily to say that it's true. It's merely to say that it sometimes involves testable hypotheses. Consider the astrological proposition that persons born with a majority of their "planets" I'm using the term in its astrological sense to include the sun and moon below the horizon are more likely to be introverts, while those with a majority of their planets above the horizon are more likely to be extroverts.

      This is a scientific hypothesis, and can be fairly easily tested by comparing the predictions made by the horoscopes of a fairly large sample of people with their scores on standard tests of introversion and extroversion.